SAYERS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD v AIG AUSTRALIA LTD

80 VR 511·Niall CJ, McLEISH and Lyons JJA
80 VR 511
SAYERS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD v AIG AUSTRALIA LTD Court of AppealNiall CJ, McLEISH and Lyons JJA 15 October, 28 November 2025[2025] VSCA 294Contract — Insurance — Loss — Claim by insured to recover loss arising from settlement of proceeding against third party — Proceeding against third party sought specific performance of contract for sale of land — Third party brought counterclaim against insured seeking to set aside contract and, in the alternative, seeking equitable compensation — Proceeding settled — Settlement terms required insured to purchase land for increased price — Insurance policy permitted insured to recover loss ‘resulting from a claim’ made against the insured — Whether ‘claim’ extended to non-monetary relief — Whether increased purchase price pursuant to settlement was loss ‘resulting from’ counterclaim — Whether loss claimed reasonable.

SPH brought proceedings seeking specific performance by DD of a contract of sale of land. DD counterclaimed, seeking relief including an order setting aside the contract and for the payment of equitable compensation. The proceeding settled, on terms including that SPH purchase the land for an additional $1,971,604 above the previously agreed purchase price.

""

Continue Reading This Report

80 VR 511

One-off Purchase

$25
This report only
Permanent access
PDF download
Best Value

Digital Subscription

$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90
All reports included
Unlimited access
Cancel anytime
Don't have an account? Create Account