KRANZ and Another v NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD

8 VR 310·Winneke P, Charles and Eames JJA
8 VR 310
8 VR 310
KRANZ and Another v NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD Court of Appeal Winneke P, Charles and Eames JJA 10, 11 September 2002, 25 July 2003 [2003] VSCA 92 Equity — Unconscionable dealings — Guarantee — Right to set aside — Family relationships — Bank — Loan for speculative share trading — Inherent risk — Surety a volunteer — Associated mortgage security — Debtor and surety — Nature of relationship — Trust and confidence — Scope of recognised categories — Whether limited to intimate family relationships — Bank’s obligation to warn surety of risk — Whether bank had requisite knowledge or put on inquiry — Whether surety in position of special disability or disadvantage — Whether special disability known or evident to bank — Surety able to read but not write English and having extensive commercial experience — Surety misled by debtor — Bank obtaining signed acknowledgment of risky nature of speculative transaction — Enforcement of guarantee and mortgage not unconscionable. T Pty Ltd, a share trader controlled by an accountant, L, and his brother, owed the respondent bank approximately $1m which was secured by registered first mortgages over a combination of investment and family-owned properties. Unable to sell the investment properties, L approached one of the bank’s managers with whom he was very well acquainted and obtained approval for a further advance of $335,000 to finance a speculative acquisition of shares in a company (part of a group of companies in which L was involved) on the basis that the sale of the shares after a holding period would yield a substantial profit which would be used to reduce T Pty Ltd’s debt to the bank. In an attempt to avoid an appearance of conflict of interest, the acquisition was effected by S Pty Ltd, another company associated with L, shortly after L had resigned as a director of that company. When the bank required additional security for the further advance, L persuaded K, who was married to the sister of L’s wife, to have M Pty Ltd, a company controlled by K, mortgage a property which it owned as tenant in common with Mr and Mrs M, the parents-in-law of L and K. For more than a decade, L had been K’s accountant and occasional business adviser. K, who could read but not write English, was an experienced businessman. K agreed to help L provided Mr and Mrs M agreed to mortgage their share of the jointly-owned property. In order to meet a deadline set by the vendor of the shares for completion of the transaction, the parties, including Mr and Mrs M, were hastily assembled by L at the bank’s premises and there signed a mortgage of the jointly-owned property and a guarantee together with an acknowledgment of the speculative nature of the transactions. The bank officials knew little more than that K was a businessman of some substance with interests in a number of properties. K signed the mortgage documents on behalf of M Pty Ltd and a personal guarantee after L misled him and thus M Pty Ltd as to the legal obligations thereby undertaken. S Pty Ltd defaulted. Mr and Mrs M settled the bank’s claim against them. A judge of the Trial Division upheld the bank’s enforcement claim against S Pty Ltd, K, M Pty Ltd and the remaining two guarantors. K and M Pty Ltd appealed.

""

Continue Reading This Report

8 VR 310

One-off Purchase

$25
This report only
Permanent access
PDF download
Best Value

Digital Subscription

$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90
All reports included
Unlimited access
Cancel anytime
Don't have an account? Create Account