7 VR 13R v SU and GOERLITZSUPREME COURT OF VICTORIAColdrey J23, 24, 29 July 2003[2003] VSC 0305Criminal law — Evidence — Ruling — Admissibility of record of interview — Suspect refused requested access to legal practitioner — Admissibility of DNA results of forensic sample obtained from suspect — Fairness and public policy discretions — Informed consent — Crimes Act 1958 (No 6231)ss 464C, 464R, 464S..
The accused Su and a co-accused were tried on a charge of kidnapping. Application was made on behalf of the accused for the exclusion of an audiotaped record of interview conducted with him by investigating police. A further application was made seeking the exclusion of the results of the analysis of a forensic sample provided by the accused on the same date. The accused had been arrested and cautioned by police. A decision was made by police to refuse the accused access to a solicitor. When the accused requested to see his solicitor he was told that he would not be allowed to do so as the investigation was still continuing. Rather than deferring the conduct of a record of interview the police interrogated the accused eliciting a number of admissions. It was only later in the interviewing process that the accused was permitted to speak to a solicitor by telephone. Forensic samples were provided by the accused to the police for DNA analysis pursuant to s 464R of the Crimes Act 1958.