33 VR 252BAINI v RCourt of AppealWarren CJ, Nettle and Ashley JJA18 September, 05 October 2011[2011] VSCA 298Criminal law — Blackmail — Multiple counts — One alleged victim — Single count relating to second alleged victim — Trial judge refusing to sever single count — Burden of showing prejudice outweighed convenience not on accused — Refusal to sever occasioned no substantial miscarriage of justice in respect of other counts — Conviction of accused on severance count brought about substantial miscarriage of justice on that count — Crimes Act 1958 (No 6231)ss 371, 372, 568(1), Sch 6, r 2..
The accused was charged on 48 counts of blackmail and convicted on 36 counts. All but one of the counts (“the Rifat counts”) related to a single alleged victim, and the remaining count (count 50) to another alleged victim. A co-accused was convicted on 20 counts. In refusing an application to sever count 50 from the presentment, the County Court trial judge did not give a formal ruling, but rather rejected the application for reasons which, the judge said, had been explored in argument. The transcript showed the judge rejected the submission that count 50, in the language of r 2 of Sch 6 of the Crimes Act 1958, was not “founded on the same facts or form[ed] or [was] part of a series of offences of the same or a similar character”. The judge also rejected the submission that he should exercise his discretion to direct a separate trial on count 50 because the accused might be prejudiced or embarrassed in his defence. At one point, in debate with counsel, the judge suggested that it was for the accused to demonstrate that prejudice “far outweigh[ed] convenience”. The accused was sentenced to an aggregate term of nine years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of six years and six months. The accused sought leave to appeal against conviction and sentence.