21 VR 310DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v AVCICourt of AppealMaxwell P, Buchanan and Redlich JJA21 July, 11 December 2008[2008] VSCA 256Criminal law — Sentencing — Standards — Director’s appeal — Challenge only to non-parole period — Sexual offences — Indecent assaults — Rape — Youthful offender — Guilty plea — Total effective sentence of 16 years — Non-parole period of nine years — Gravity of offences — Aggravating factors — Wanton violence — Impact on victims — Repeat offending — Six separate incidents over four months — Offender’s awareness of victims’ fear and distress — Cumulative blameworthiness — Community fear and protection — Denunciation — Need for salutary sentence — Non-parole period increased to 11 years.
A pleaded guilty in the County Court to seven counts of rape, two counts of indecent assault, three counts of robbery and one count of aggravated burglary arising out of attacks on six separate occasions, each time on a different female victim and on four of which occasions the victim was raped. The prosecutor submitted to the trial judge that the minimum term required would at least be double figures. The periods of imprisonment imposed for the respective rape offences were as follows: five years, five years, seven years, six years, six years, six years, and 10 years. The judge imposed a total effective sentence of 16 years’ imprisonment, and directed that the accused serve a minimum of nine years before becoming eligible for parole. The Director of Public Prosecutions appealed against the non-parole period.