R v KRASUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA - COURT OF APPEALWinneke P, Brooking and Ormiston JJA13, 22 September 1999[1999] VSCA 0157Criminal law — Joinder of counts — Sexual offences — Several complainants — Separate trials — Discretion to order separate trials — Warning to jury regarding evidence of uncharged acts — Application to discharge jury — Sentence — Whether manifestly excessive — Crimes Act 1958 (No. 6231)ss. 45,
47A,
321M,
372..
The accused was charged with sexual offences against three young girls, all sisters. It was ordered that the trial of the charges involving the youngest girl be severed from the trial of the charges involving the other two. In respect of the two older girls, the accused was charged with maintaining a sexual relationship, contrary to s. 47A of the Crimes Act 1958, and in respect of one of these girls there were two charges of penetration and two charges of attempted penetration. The Crown had said at the start of the trial that, for the two penetration charges, it would rely on eye-witness evidence of the other girl. One of these charges was withdrawn from the jury. The prosecutor requested the judge to give the jury a warning about the use they could make of evidence of uncharged acts of penetration from the complainant of the penetration charges. Defence counsel opposed this course and sought a discharge of the jury on the ground that separate trials should have been ordered. The judge refused this application. The accused was found guilty of the charges of maintaining a sexual relationship and attempted penetration but acquitted of the remaining penetration charge. He was sentenced to a total effective sentence of six years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of four years. He applied for leave to appeal against conviction and sentence.