AMP FIRE and GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD v EMANUELLI

[1984] VR 607·YOUNG CJ, KAYE and BROOKING JJ
[1984] VR 607
AMP FIRE and GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD v EMANUELLI SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA FULL COURT YOUNG CJ, KAYE and BROOKING JJ 24, 25 May, 16 December 1983
[1984] VR 607
Insurance — Motor vehicle insurance — Motor vehicle towing a trailer in unsafe and unroadworthy condition — Exclusion relieving insurer from liability where "motor vehicle" used in unsafe or unroadworthy condition — Whether the words "motor vehicle" include trailer. . A policy of insurance indemnified the insured against, inter alia, liability in damages arising out of the use of his motor vehicle. The policy defined a motor vehicle as a mechanically propelled vehicle. A clause in the policy provided that for the purposes of indemnity against liability in damages "the term 'motor vehicle'... should include a trailer whilst the trailer was attached to the motor vehicle". An exclusion clause in the policy excluded liability when the "motor vehicle" was being used in an unsafe or unroadworthy condition. An accident occurred whilst the insured was driving his motor car with a trailer attached causing damage to a school. The school sued the insured who joined the insurer as a third party. The Judge found that the insured was negligent and that at the time of the accident the trailer, but not the car, was in an unsafe and unroadworthy condition. The insurer denied liability relying on the exclusion clause. The Judge found against the insurer. On appeal:--

""

Continue Reading This Report

[1984] VR 607

One-off Purchase

$25
This report only
Permanent access
PDF download
Best Value

Digital Subscription

$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90
All reports included
Unlimited access
Cancel anytime
Don't have an account? Create Account