[1982] VR 921
RE PALMDALE INSURANCE LTD IN LIQUIDATION
SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
GOBBO, J
9-13 February, 15 May 1981
[1982] VR 921
Insurance — Brokers and agents — Liability of brokers and agents to insurer
for unpaid premiums — Authority of broker or agent to receive return premium
on cancellation of policy — Liability of brokers and agents to repay return
commission on cancellation of policy — Treasurer directing insurer to cease
carrying on business — Direction complied with — Insurer unable to perform
obligations under policies — Whether contracts of insurance repudiated — Insurance Act 1973 (Cth.), s62.
.
(1) Marine policies of insurance apart, an insurance broker or agent is not
liable to pay to the insurer the premiums in respect of a policy of insurance
issued by the insurer to the policy-holder at the request of the broker or
agent whether the broker has received the premium from the policy-holder or
not, unless there is a contractual stipulation to the contrary. In non-marine
policies of insurance, where a premium is received by the insurer's own agent,
then the agent is liable to account to the insurer for such premiums.
Shee v Clarkson (1810) 12 East 507; 104 ER 199; Minett v Forrester (1819) 4
Taunt 542; 128 ER 441; Power v Butcher (1829) 10 B and C 329; 109 ER 472;
Moore v Graham (1868) 5 WW and A'B(L) 229; Universo Marine Co. of Milan v
Merchants Marine Insurance Co., [1897] 2 QB 93; Antiseptic Bedding Co. v
Gurofski (1915) 21 DLR 483; Tarleton v De Veure (1940) 132 ALR 343(U.S.);
Balent v National Insurance Co. of New Zealand Ltd. (1959) 59 SR (NSW) 275;
Wilson v Avec Audio-Visual Equipment Ltd., [1974] 1 Lloyd's Rep 81, referred
to.
(2) An insurer's inability to perform its obligations under its policies by
reason of the Treasurer's directions under s62(2) of the Insurance Act 1973
(Cth.) can amount to a repudiation by the insurer of its contracts of
insurance which affords the policy-holders the right to elect to terminate the
policies for breach and sue for damages. In the present case, however, the
evidence did not indicate termination by policy-holders for breach but only
cancellation pursuant to the terms of the policies.
In re The Federal Building Assurance Co. Ltd. (1934) 34 SR (NSW) 499, referred
to .
(3) Return premiums payable by the insurer upon cancellation of a policy
should be paid to the policy-holder and not to the broker or agent who
arranged the policy. In the present case, there was no evidence of an implied
authority in the broker or agent to receive return premiums.
Re Colin Williams (Insurance) Pty. Ltd. (In Liq.) and the Companies Act,
[1975] 1 NSWLR 130, approved.
(4) Where policies of insurance are arranged through insurance brokers or
agents who have received commission therefor, such brokers or agents are
liable, on cancellation of the policies consequent upon the insurer going into
liquidation, to repay to the insurer a rateable amount of return commission.
Re Colin Williams (Insurance) Pty. Ltd. (In Liq) and the Companies Act, [1975]
1 NSWLR 130, followed.
Continue Reading This Report
[1982] VR 921
Best Value
Digital Subscription
$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90