[1982] VR 331
DE NIER v BEICHT
SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA FULL COURT
LUSH, KAYE and BROOKING, JJ
10 September 1981
[1982] VR 331
Limitation of actions — Money due under contract of sale — Defence relying on
parol evidence of purchaser — Death of purchaser — Administratrix of
purchaser's estate substituted as defendant — Dismissal of action for want of
prosecution — New writ issued — Whether findings of "rare and exceptional
circumstances" — Action struck out as abuse of process — Whether court had
inherent jurisdiction — Limitation of Actions Act 1958 (No. 6295)
.
In August 1975 the plaintiffs commenced an action as vendors whereby they
claimed from a purchaser money payable under a contract of sale of a business.
The purchaser died in April 1979 before the trial of the action. In May 1980,
the purchaser's widow, as administratrix of the purchaser's estate, was
substituted as defendant in the action. In June 1980 the substituted defendant
took out a summons for dismissal of the action for want of prosecution. The
order sought was granted by a Master upon grounds, inter alia, that the
plaintiffs had delayed inordinately without explanation, and there could not
be a fair trial without injustice to the substituted defendant. In September
1980, and before the expiration of the limitation period, the plaintiffs
issued a second writ in respect of the same cause of action in which the
administratrix was the defendant. Subsequently, an appeal from the Master's
order was dismissed and the substituted defendant applied to a Master for an
order staying or dismissing the second action. The Master allowed the
application upon the basis that there had been findings of "rare and
exceptional circumstances" which had justified the striking out of the first
action; and in purported exercise of the court's inherent jurisdiction,
ordered that the second action be struck out as an abuse of process. The
plaintiffs appealed from that order to a Judge who allowed the appeal. On
application by the substituted defendant for leave to appeal to the Full
Court,
Continue Reading This Report
[1982] VR 331
Best Value
Digital Subscription
$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90