WELSH v CORNFOOT

[1973] VR 21·LUSH, J
[1973] VR 21
WELSH v CORNFOOT SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA LUSH, J 31 July, 9 August 1972
[1973] VR 21
Company law — Failure to lodge return of allotment of shares — Failure to lodge notice of address of registered office — Failure to lodge return of officers of company — Documents to be lodged within one month after incorporation or allotment — Directors charged with breaches of such provisions — No knowledge by directors of breaches until after the period of one month had expired — Whether each director an "officer... in default" — Whether officer liable for permitting completed offences to continue — Whether obligations continue from the end of time provided until compliance — Non- continuing and completed offences — Operation of "default" penalty considered — Companies Act 1961 (No. 6839), s54(1), s54(7), s58(2), s58(5), s59(4), s59(7). s66, s67, s70(7), s112(1), s112(2), s128(1), s128(4), s134(6), s134(7), s135(5), s135(6), s135(10), s379(1), s380. . S54(1) of the Companies Act 1961 requires a company to lodge a return of the allotment of any shares within one month thereafter, s112(1) provides for the giving of notice of the situation of the registered office of a company within one month after the date of its incorporation, and s134(6) requires a company to lodge within one month after incorporation a return of its directors, managers and secretaries. Each of these sections contains a provision whereby "If default is made...every officer of the company who is in default shall be guilty of an offence against this Act", and further both a penalty and a default penalty are provided for. S380(1) of the Act stipulates that wherever the expression "Default Penalty" appears, then any person convicted of an offence under such a section "shall be guilty of a further offence against this Act if the offence continues after he is so convicted and liable to an additional penalty for each day during which the offence so continues...", whilst s380(2) provides: "Where any offence is committed by a person by reason of his failure to comply with any provision of this Act by or under which he is required or directed to do anything within a particular period, that offence for the purposes of subs(1) of this section shall be deemed to continue so long as the thing so required or directed to be done by him remains undone, notwithstanding that such period has elapsed", and s380(3) provides: "For the purposes of any provision of this Act which provides that an officer of a company...who is in default is guilty of an offence against or is liable to a penalty or punishment the phrase officer who is in default or any like phrase means any officer of the company...who knowingly and wilfully - (a) is guilty of the offence; or (b) authorizes or permits the commission of the offence. The two defendants, as directors of a company, were each charged with offences under s54, s112 and s134 of the Act. The company was incorporated in 1968 and an allotment of shares was then made, and none of the documents required by the three sections were filed until October 1971. In June 1969 each of the defendants was interviewed, and from that time it was clear that they knew that the returns required had not been filed. The informations charged that the offences had been committed on 14 July 1969 and each information was drawn in terms that the defendant permitted the company to commit the relevant offence. The magistrate before whom the informations were heard held that there was no evidence that within the period of one month relevant to each information either of the defendants knew that the necessary return had not been lodged and, therefore, there was no evidence to bring them within the definition of "officer...in default", and dismissed the informations.

""

Continue Reading This Report

[1973] VR 21

One-off Purchase

$25
This report only
Permanent access
PDF download
Best Value

Digital Subscription

$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90
All reports included
Unlimited access
Cancel anytime
Don't have an account? Create Account