EUMERALLA FINANCE CO PTY LTD v LAW INSTITUTE OF VICTORIA

[1972] VR 708·LUSH, J
[1972] VR 708
EUMERALLA FINANCE CO PTY LTD v LAW INSTITUTE OF VICTORIA SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA LUSH, J 26-28 October, 17 December 1971
[1972] VR 708
Legal profession — Solicitors' Guarantee Fund — Compensation — Loss suffered from defalcations by firm of solicitors — Payments by firm to or for benefit of plaintiff — Whether to be brought into account — "Reduction of loss" — Rule in Clayton's Case — Application to payments into and from solicitors' trust account for specific purpose — Legal Profession Practice Act 1958 (No. 6291), s64. . In an action under the Legal Profession Practice Act 1958 in which the plaintiff claimed compensation from the Solicitors' Guarantee Fund in respect of a number of defalcations of moneys paid by it to a firm of solicitors, the only disputed matters raised by the statement of claim were allegations that a defalcation occurred of moneys paid by the plaintiff to the firm for investment in loans secured by mortgages from L. The disputed issues arising from the defence, were whether four sums of money, admittedly paid to or for the advantage of the plaintiff, were to be brought into account against the amount of the loss caused by the defalcations. The four sums were not provided by or for the benefit of the plaintiff and were paid from the firm's trust account (i) to pay to the plaintiff interest on the mortgages from L; (ii) to provide the principal sum secured by a mortgage from B, which was repaid to the plaintiff according to its terms; (iii) to repay to the plaintiff a sum advanced on mortgage by the plaintiff to W, and some interest on that sum; (iv) to make a payment for the plaintiff's benefit in a transaction with K.

""

Continue Reading This Report

[1972] VR 708

One-off Purchase

$25
This report only
Permanent access
PDF download
Best Value

Digital Subscription

$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90
All reports included
Unlimited access
Cancel anytime
Don't have an account? Create Account