[1971] VR 252
RE BRUNT, DECEASED;
BRUNT AND MCNAUGHTON v COMMISSIONER OF PROBATE DUTIES
SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
MENHENNITT J
11, 12, 16 June, 01 October 1970
[1971] VR 252
Probate duty — Notional estate — Shares in company controlled by deceased — Shares issued at par — Nominal value less than full value upon issue — Whether
issued otherwise than for a full consideration in money or money's worth — Shares deemed subject-matter of gift by deceased — Whether bona fide
possession and enjoyment capable of being assumed by donee while company
controlled by deceased — Probate Duty Act 1962 (No. 6890), s7(1)(d)(ii),
s(2)(b).
.
For the purposes of s7(2)(b) of the Probate Duty Act 1962, shares are issued
otherwise than for a full consideration in money or money's worth, if the
consideration is less than the full value of the shares upon issue.
Where shares in a company controlled by the deceased are so issued to persons
other than the deceased, s7(2)(b) produces the result that whether those
persons in fact assume bona fide possession and enjoyment of the shares or not
the shares are part of the notional estate of the deceased unless more than
three years before the death of the deceased the company ceased to be
controlled by him.
The deceased died domiciled in Victoria on 13 April 1965. On 1 April 1958 and
at all times thereafter until his death he was the governing director of a
company and controlled the composition of its board of directors. The company
was, therefore, during those times a company which by virtue of s7(3)(a) of
the Probate Duty Act 1962 is to be deemed for the purposes of s7(2)(b) of that
Act to have been controlled by the deceased. The capital of the company was
divided into shares of $2 each. On 1 April 1958 the company issued 50 shares
at par to each of four persons who paid the company for them the nominal value
thereof in cash. At the time of issue the value to the shareholders of each of
the 200 shares so issued was $2900. At the time of the death of the deceased
the value of each of the said shares was $336. In each year after the said
shares were issued the company declared dividends which were duly paid to each
of the shareholders according to their holdings. Within three years
immediately before the death of the deceased the total amount of the dividends
paid in respect of the 200 shares was $38,450.
The executors of the will of the deceased duly filed in the office of the
Commissioner of Probate Duties a statement in accordance with s11 of the said
Act. The Commissioner determined the final balance of the deceased's estate
and made an assessment of the duty payable thereon. In the final balance as so
determined the Commissioner included a sum of $105,604 as "Gift inter vivos
being issue of shares for inadequate consideration plus dividends on shares".
The said sum was made up of $67,154 (being the value of the said 200 shares at
the date of death less a proportion of the amount paid for them by the
shareholders) and the said amount of $38,450.
The executors lodged an objection which the Commissioner disallowed. They then
appealed under s19 of the said Act against his decision.
Continue Reading This Report
[1971] VR 252
Best Value
Digital Subscription
$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90