1925 VLR 514R. v. O’SULLIVAN Supreme Court of Victoria IRVINE, C.J., CUSSEN, J., and WEIGALL, A.-J. April 1, 1925, 11 May 1925Criminal law — Obtaining by false pretences — Agent taking possession for principal — Whether agent "obtains" — Intent to defraud — Jury must be expressly directed as to — Unless intent necessarily involved in representation — Misdirection — New trial — Crimes Act 1915 (No. 2637), ss. 181 (a), 182, 593 (b).
The accused was presented in the Court of General Sessions, under sec. 181 (a) of the Crimes Act 1915, for obtaining goods by false pretences, and was found guilty. The evidence disclosed that the accused obtained possession of certain goods from one F., as the agent for his employer, the purchaser, and the false representations charged consisted of certain statements bearing upon the position and business standing of his employer. The accused had, in fact, authority from his employer to make the purchase on his behalf, and the goods were ultimately delivered to the employer, but were not paid for. There was evidence that F. was in fact induced by the false representations to part with the goods to the accused; and, on the direction given by the learned Chairman to the jury, they must have found that one or more of the false representations was or were made, and that F. was induced thereby to part with his goods. There was abundant evidence on which the jury might have found an intent to defraud on the part of the accused.