1925 VLR 27THE PAKENHAM UPPER FRUIT COMPANY LIMITED v. CROSBY In the High Court of Australia [Coram KNOX, C.J., ISAACS, RICH, GAVAN DUFFY AND STARKE, JJ.] May 6, 1924, 15 December 1924Company — Co-operative fruit-growing — Agency for sale of members' fruit — Contract — Whether articles of association constitute a contract binding upon a member in his individual capacity of grower — Obligation to deliver 95 per cent. of fruit crop to company — Provision for termination by notice — Power in company to alter articles — Restraint of trade — Specific performance — Injunction — Right of company to specific performance of alleged contract and to injunction — Principles on which granted — Indefinite terms — Discretion in company to refuse to receive fruit — No injunction where contract for delivery of chattels on sale — Absence of negative stipulation — Effect on application for injunction — Objects of company — What constitutes — Companies Act (1915), No. 2361, s. 11 — Practice — Parties — Non-joinder of third person to whom fruit sold by grower.
The plaintiff, a company registered in 1918 under the Companies Act 1915, and formed on a co-operative basis for the purpose (inter alia) of acting as general agent for its members and others for the purchase, sale and disposal of fruit and other produce, sought by this action against the defendant, a shareholder and a grower of fruit—(1) an injunction restraining him from delivering to any person, company or corporation other than the plaintiff his first crop of apples for the then present season, capable of being marketed and ready, suitable and fit for harvesting and/or picking and grown on his property, to the extent of 95 per cent, of the crop, and (2) specific performance of an alleged agreement to deliver his fruit to the plaintiff and constituted (in substance) by the defendant’s application for shares, the company’s notice of allotment, and article 5A of the company’s amended articles of association. There was no claim for damages.