R. v. AIKEN

[1925] VLR 265·IRVINE, C.J., CUSSEN, J., and WEIGALL, A.-J.
[1925] VLR 265
1925 VLR 265
R. v. AIKEN Supreme Court of Victoria IRVINE, C.J., CUSSEN, J., and WEIGALL, A.-J. 01 April 1925 Criminal law — Evidence — Identification — Admissibility of evidence of similar offences — Rule as to — Larceny as bailee — Presentment on two charges — Charges heard together — Misdirection — Similarity of means adopted in committing offences — Combining evidence as to on one charge with that on other charge — Whether permissible — Failure to warn jury to confine attention to evidence relating to each separate charge — Substantial miscarriage of justice — New trial — Whether separate trials of separate charges — Crimes Act 1915 (No. 2637), ss. 593, 594 .

Where an accused person is prosecuted on two charges of committing a similar offence, the charges being combined in the one presentment, and being tried together, a mere similarity in the means adopted in the two cases, where those means might have been adopted in either case by any one of an indefinite number of persons, and where no other connection, either in the mind of the accused or, in fact, is shown to have existed, cannot justify, on the question of identity, the combining of the evidence in the one case with that in the other.

""

Continue Reading This Report

[1925] VLR 265

One-off Purchase

$25
This report only
Permanent access
PDF download
Best Value

Digital Subscription

$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90
All reports included
Unlimited access
Cancel anytime
Don't have an account? Create Account