1925 VLR 170JAMES v. WENDEL Supreme Court of Victoria IRVINE, C.J., MANN and MacFARLAN, JJ. 06 March 1925County Court — Practice — Costs — Payment into Court — Counterclaim — Defence raising same matters as counterclaim — Amount recovered less than amount paid in — County Court Act 1915 (No. 2636), s. 62.
In an action in the County Court on a building contract the defendant paid into Court a sum less than that claimed, with a denial of liability, and the proper amount for costs, and at the same time gave notice of a counterclaim. At the trial the defendant raised as defences the same matters as those in his counterclaim. The trial Judge found that the amount due to the plaintiff, if not reduced by any deductions on account of the defences raised, was more than the amount paid into Court, but on making the deductions which he considered proper to be made in respect of these defences, he gave judgment for the plaintiff for a sum less than the amount paid into Court, and awarded to the plaintiff costs only up to the time of payment in; but, holding that the matter was one of law under sec. 62 of the County Court Act, 1915, and not one of discretion, he ordered the plaintiff to pay the costs incurred by the defendant after that date.