CATTANACH v. MACPHERSON

[1908] VLR 390·MADDEN, C.J.
[1908] VLR 390
1908 VLR 390
CATTANACH v. MACPHERSON Supreme Court of Victoria MADDEN, C.J. March 11, 12, 1908, 14 April 1908 Executor — Commission — Probate in Scotland and Victoria — Victorian executors, also attorneys of trustees of will in Scotland — Agreement as to commission of — Costs of executor passing accounts — Administration and Probate Act 1890 (No. 1060), s. 26 .

A testator who died domiciled in Scotland by his will appointed certain persons executors and trustees thereof in Scotland, and devised and bequeathed to them all his property, including his property in Australia, on certain trusts. Probate of this will was sealed in Victoria on the application of persons duly authorized by power of attorney in that behalf. The Scotch trustees of the testator’s will from time to time by powers of attorney appointed these persons to be their attorneys (inter alia) to get in the Victorian assets and remit the moneys representing same to Scotland, and authorized them to deduct their expenses and a reasonable "gratification" for their services. The attorneys got in the outstanding Victorian assets, and for a period of eleven years remitted so much of the moneys representing the same to Scotland as was required from time to time by the Scotch trustees, deducting therefrom as the reasonable "gratification" for their services 5 per cent. on the income got in by them, and in one exceptional case 5 per cent. on corpus. This last-mentioned deduction was challenged by the Scotch trustees, but, after explanation, was subsequently allowed by them. The plaintiff, one of such attorneys as aforesaid, being dissatisfied with his remuneration, and failing to induce the Scotch trustees to increase it, then instituted this action, claiming (inter alia)—(1) to be discharged from the office of trustee of the testator’s will in Victoria, (2) the appointment of another trustee in his place, and (3) an order that he be at liberty to pass his accounts and be allowed commission.

""

Continue Reading This Report

[1908] VLR 390

One-off Purchase

$25
This report only
Permanent access
PDF download
Best Value

Digital Subscription

$45/mo
or $450/yrSAVE $90
All reports included
Unlimited access
Cancel anytime
Don't have an account? Create Account